Last week Joan Burton, the Labour Party minister for Social Protection, gave an address to the Leinster Society of Chartered Accountants. You can read the full speech at the Department of Social Protection site. I noticed as I was inserting the link to the site that the URL still contains that quaint 20th century word ‘Welfare’.

Invoking Barack Obama, Burton made announcements to the assembled chartered accountants about her department’s ‘activation’ measures, under the heading ‘The Case for Activation’, thereby presenting what is a key element of the Troika’s Economic Adjustment Programme for Ireland as though it were the product of democratic deliberation by a sovereign government. ‘Activation’ is the name given by ‘the economists’ (as Burton calls them) to a series of bureaucratic measures aimed at making life difficult for people who are unemployed. As Burton puts it:

research shows that the longer a person is unemployed, the less effort they make to find employment.  People become defeatist and lose motivation…


For example, I am trying to ensure that people don’t find the security of the social welfare system more attractive than the risky world of work.

Reading this, I was reminded of the following quote by Mont Pelerin’s finest and Margaret Thatcher’s intellectual hero, Friedrich von Hayek, in the Road to Serfdom:

We cannot blame our young men when they prefer the safe, salaried position to the risk of enterprise

Mutatis mutandis, the men and the women kept in unemployment through deliberate policy choices by the government in collaboration with the troika, where untold billions of public money are spent keeping banks and interests associated with the property market afloat instead of being used for investment programmes (here, ‘the economists’ might talk about opportunity costs), are safe and salaried, whereas those out in the world of work are the risk takers.

(The risks of poor physical and mental health, future loss of income and so on and so forth associated with unemployment, and generated by deliberate government policy, are the wrong type of risk.)

An example of the latter might be chartered accountants, who provide services to the financial services industry, and, indeed, the public. NAMA, for instance, has contracts with all four of The Big Four. The Chairman of the Chartered Accountants Leinster Society, which Burton addressed to detail her plans about what she was going to do with all the risk shirkers, works for KPMG.

It is hard to work out what the association is between the Chartered Accountants Leinster Society and the Labour Party. Perhaps there is none at all.


But it is diverting to note that on the morning of the ICTU march of 27th November 2010, which was the last mass mobilisation in Ireland, members of the Labour Party held their Pre-Budget Forum at Chartered Accountants House on Pearse Street, the headquarters of the Chartered Accountants Leinster Society.


They then made their way over to take part in the march, which would prove, in time, to have enervated far more than it energised, once the Labour Party, backed by unions, took its place in government to do the will of the Troika, as they had agreed with Dominique Strauss-Kahn.

And now Joan Burton returns to the Chartered Accountants Leinster Society, and encourages them to take up the offer, in their firms, of the free labour offered to them under the JobBridge scheme, which helps keep wages low but introduces unemployed people to the risky world of work, id est, working for nothing.

“I have also been reforming the social welfare system to ensure that work pays for welfare recipients”, said Burton. That’s a pretty apt way of describing the introduction of a scheme that supplies free labour to an industry sustained by massive public subsidy.

Well, here is a quick comparison of the gulf between the risk takers and the defeatists. It shows the gap between the salary packages of Chartered Accountant Managing Directors in Industry & Commerce and Financial Services (source: Chartered Accountants Leinster Society survey) , and what a ‘Jobseeker’ (an Orwellian term used to place responsibility on the person who is unemployed, not State institutions, for the fact of his or her unemployment) received annually, during the recession (source: Department of Finance Budget briefings).


Which group does the Irish Labour Party serve more faithfully?




Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “Risk

  1. CMK

    A most apposite post, Richard! Re: the jobsbridge scam, I got the following email today from Griffith College Dublin, where I had done some night courses a couple of years ago. I’ve posted it up a couple of other places tonight, but it’s unbe-fucking-lievable that this shit is happening under a part Labour government funded by my trade unions subs!! A bit of context: a MA or LLM in Griffith can set you back 11,000 per year and a BA can set you back up to 9,000 per year. **********************************************************Dear CMKWe are delighted to announce that the college has a number of Internships available with the National Internship Scheme – JobBridge.Through these Internships, we aim to provide graduates with the skills needed to bridge the gap between completion of study and the beginning of their careers.There are currently three internships available in the college, they are:Front Office Administrator – Griffith Halls of Residence (click here for more information).International Office Assistant – Griffith College Dublin (click here for more information).Human Resources Administrator – Griffith College Dublin (click here for more information).Please note that this is an Internship. An allowance of €50.00 per week is added to the successful candidates Social Welfare payment. (Please see http://www.jobbridge.ie for further details).Furthermore, if you are not eligible or interested in applying for either internship but know someone who might, please feel free to send them these details.As always, we hope this e-mail finds you well and if you have any queries please don’t hesitate to contact the Alumni Office.Kind RegardsGriffith College Dublinwww.gcd.ie

  2. Richard

    Shocking stuff CMK!

  3. Very informative post. I remember finding it striking that Labour held an event in conflict with the ICTU march and wrote to Joan Burton enquiring why it had happened.To the best of my memory she did not take part in the march.We have been discussing sackings and replacement with interns on http://www.politicalworld.org and I will link this post back to the discussion.Joan Burton herself is an accountant and recently was on RTE promoting a scheme in which accountants give advice to distressed mortgage holders for a 250 euro subsidised fee paid by government – nice little handout to accountants and most unlikely to result in a loan write off.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s